· One rhetorical fallacy that has to do with the logos of the
argument is post hoc. This is when
one event is assumed to cause another event, just because it occurs beforehand.
This is fallacious because in reality, there could be one or more other
confounding variables that that also contribute to a result. The first event
may not even contribute at all to the second. A way to identify this fallacy is
to think critically and ask, "are there any other events that could have
caused this result in addition to or instead of the event the author is arguing
is the cause?" The author may overlooking other major factors that cause
something to occur. One example of this fallacy that comes to mind is when
people blame a president for causing a problem in a country just because he
became the president prior to it happening. However, we should know that there
are many events and trends over the course of time that could lead to a
conflict such as an economic crisis and the president should not be the only
person or thing to blame. For example some might blame President Bush for the
increase in unemployment levels in the 2000s, but who is to say that the same
problems would not occur with a different president in office? If someone were
to think that it I all Bushes fault, this could be an example of the post hoc fallacy. Another more common
example of this fallacy is with various superstitions. Many people have
superstitions where they think doing a specific action or ritual before an
event makes them perform better or gives them good luck. They think this
because they did it once or a few times and an event or performance went well
for them. For example, on my basketball team in high school, a girl on the team
French braided my hair before the game and then in the game, I played very well
and made all my free throws. The next game, she braided my hair again and I
played well again. She told me it was her "lucky braids" that did the
trick, but I recognized this fallacy and knew that the braids did not cause me
to play well. I knew that there were other more logical factors like working
hard at practice and trying my best in the game. These are some examples and
ways to recognize the logical fallacy of post
hoc.
No comments:
Post a Comment